Born January 16, 1757, in a house built by his carpenter father, Samuel grew up surrounded by architecture and craftsmanship. Both Samuel and his brothers, Joseph and Angier, were trained as carpenters in their father’s workshop and Samuel showed a particular aptitude for not only housebuilding, but delicate carving work as well. After their father’s death in 1777, the McIntire brothers continued in the family business, with Samuel completing one of his first prominent commissions in 1782. The project, a three-story mansion for merchant and Friendship co-owner Jerathmiel Peirce, drew continued attention to the 25-year-old craftsman and he continued receiving prominent commissions throughout his life, notably through the continued patronage of the millionaire Derby family, whose summer house he had designed in 1793. Samuel continued to work within his family business as he became more and more successful, with his brothers and even his son working for him on the construction of houses while he handled the intricate carving work. The Derbys would call on him again as one of several architects involved in the design of the Derby mansion once occupying the site of Old Town Hall.
In 1805 McIntire was commissioned to construct Hamilton Hall, a place for Federalists to meet now that they were unwilling to mingle with their Republican neighbors, a structure that remains to this day one of his most notable architectural works. On February 6, 1811, Samuel McIntire died suddenly at the age of 54, after complaining of an obstruction in his chest. The Rev. Bentley, an early supporter of Samuel, eulogized him as such in his diary: “In Sculpture he had no rival in New England.”